![]() |
| Book Review: The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate on Identity, Community and Justice — A representative image. |
File Information
| Document Information | Details |
|---|---|
| Title | Book Review: The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate: On Identity, Community and Justice |
| Article Credit | Gandhi Marg, ISSN: 0016-4437, Vol.: 44, Issue: 4, Year: 2023, (Pubd in: Gandhimargjournal.org) |
| Author | Sanjeev Kumar (Professor of Political Science, Zakir Husain Delhi College, University of Delhi) Ratika Gaur (Assistant Professor of Political Science, Hindu College, University of Delhi) |
| Subject | A review of Bindu Puri's The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate (Springer, 2022), which reads the dispute through decoloniality and the Purva-Paksa method. |
| Category | Book Review |
| Institution | Gandhi Peace Foundation, New Delhi |
| Country of Publication | India |
| Main Topics | Gandhi's theological vocabulary of ahimsa, sewa, tapasya and swaraj, Ambedkar's critique of Gandhi on agency and personhood, Decoloniality and the Purva-Paksa method, Memory and suffering in the conflict, Untouchability, separate electorates, conversion and varna |
| Number of Pages | 5 |
| Language | English |
| File Type | |
| File Size | 46.8 KB |
Summary Note of this Document
Book Review: The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate: On Identity, Community and Justice
Sanjeev Kumar and Ratika Gaur review Bindu Puri's The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate: On Identity, Community & Justice, published by Springer in Singapore in February 2022. The review begins with Gandhi's notion of identity, equality, community and justice, built on a theological vocabulary of ahimsa, sewa, tapasya and swaraj, which Ambedkar's critique later pushed to the margin by pointing to its inability to answer the Dalit demand for agency and its loss of personhood. Puri aims to offer a corrective to scholarship that either dismisses Gandhi's thick swaraj as impractical or denies Gandhians the ability to speak for Dalit experience. She uses the lens of decoloniality within the Purva-Paksa method to trace such dismissals to the incompatible assumptions that Ambedkarites and Gandhi hold about the nature of the self, about the link between the self's attachments and a conception of justice, and about how one comes to the truth about the past. The five chapters, which the reviewers call somewhat unstructured, set out the two sides' responses on untouchability, separate electorates, Hinduism, conversion, temple entry, caste, varna, history and tradition, and argue that no meaningful dialogue was possible because both used the same words with very different meanings. The reviewers conclude that the book is of value to readers who want Gandhi-Ambedkar scholarship beyond polemic and hagiography.
Core Themes
- Gandhi's theological language of justice and community
- Ambedkar's critique concerning Dalit agency
- Decoloniality and the Purva-Paksa method
- Memory and the politics of suffering
- Scholarship beyond polemic and hagiography
Keywords
About Dr. B. R. Ambedkar
Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar was born in 1891 as the fourteenth and youngest child of an army Subedar in Mhow. Born into the Mahar caste, which was considered untouchable, Bhimrao faced many hardships at school. He had to sit on a gunny sack that he brought from home. He was not allowed to touch the water vessel or cup, so he could drink water only when the school peon was present to pour it for him. He later described this experience with the words, “No peon, no water.” His mother died when he was very young, and he had a difficult childhood. However, he was the only one of his siblings to pass his examinations and continue to high school, becoming the first person from his community to attend Elphinstone College. With a scholarship from the Maharaja of Baroda, he went on to study at Columbia University and the London School of Economics. He earned doctorates in economics and trained as a barrister at Gray’s Inn. According to the account supplied for this biography, his books were lost when his ship was torpedoed during the First World War.
Despite his education, Ambedkar continued to face prejudice. When he returned to India, he was required to work in Baroda but had to leave the position because of discrimination. His business providing investment consultancy failed when clients learned that he belonged to a community considered untouchable. While working as a professor in Mumbai, his colleagues objected to the idea of him sharing a water jug with his students. These experiences helped spur his activism. He established newspapers to give a voice to marginalized people. He led the Mahad Satyagraha, asserting Dalits’ right to collect water from a public tank, and publicly burned the Manusmriti in 1927. In 1932, he negotiated the Poona Pact with Mahatma Gandhi. Although it involved a difficult compromise, the pact provided reserved seats in legislatures for the Depressed Classes. Ambedkar was outspoken in public life but private by nature. His wife Ramabai died in 1935, and he filled his home in Bombay with a large personal library reported to contain more than 50,000 books. He declared, “I am born a Hindu, but I will not die as one.”
During the period of Indian independence, Jawaharlal Nehru invited Ambedkar to become India’s first Law Minister. Ambedkar chaired the Drafting Committee that prepared the Constitution of India, which abolished the practice of untouchability and established civil liberties and constitutional safeguards, including reservations for historically oppressed communities. He acknowledged the contribution of other constitutional experts, including B. N. Rau, who had prepared an earlier draft. Because of his poor health, including diabetes, Ambedkar married Savita, a doctor who cared for him. In October 1956, he converted to Buddhism in Nagpur along with a vast gathering of followers, commonly estimated at around half a million. He died in his sleep just weeks later, shortly after completing his final major work, The Buddha and His Dhamma. He was posthumously awarded the Bharat Ratna in 1990. His message, “Educate, agitate, organise,” continues to inspire people seeking equality and social justice.
Complete Ambedkar Research Collection
Download the entire collection of Ambedkar research PDFs available on HISTORY MARG
